Monday, October 8, 2012

Analysis of 2012 Presidential Debate

  1. Red Herring - Obama at the very beginning mentions his anniversary and marriage 20 years ago, slightly avoiding the first topic and appeals to more emotional issue or already saying he might not be at the top of his game because of the time of the debate
  2. Dramatic monolog - Mitt Romney gives the example of the people in Ohio and other places in and out of jobs
  3. Imagery - Mitt Romney's example of unemployment (shows sadness)
  4. Tone - Mitt's voice sounds reverent (at the beginning) and relatively calm throughout the debate
  5. Structure - Mitt is structured and organized (has multiple lists) whereas Obama seems quite scattered brained
  6. Strawperson - Mitt is tearing Obama down by correcting him multiple times.  Obama is on the defensive most of the time through out the debate
  7. Post Hoc - both use it as explaining their policies
  8. Allusion - Romney refers to his boys and relates how repetition does not make stuff true.  Obama uses allusion when talking about his loving Grandmother and mentioning the previous presidents (also tries to reestablish creditably)
  9. False Authority - Both candidates were throwing numbers and statistics but never really completely explaining them
  10. Repetition - both constantly repeat their policies, "$5 million tax cut..." (I thought it got kind of annoying)
  11. Guilty by association - Obama infers to Pres. Bush's "mess" when Obama came in office and seems to be implying that that could happen when another Republican goes into office
Other interesting facts:
        Obama was standing on one leg; this looks less firm and unsure, whereas Romney stands firm on two feet not slouching over the pulpit. 
        Obama kept stuttering and looking down.  In comparison  Romney was calm and spoke with confidence and determination.  (Though one could tell both seemed to really not want to be there, Romney just hid it better and lasted longer).
        Romney was leading the debate (he had complete control, even over the mediator man).  Obama was constantly on the defense and Romney happily took the offensive and drove the debate in his favor. 

1 comment:

  1. Great rhetorical tools! We both picked out some of the same tools, but we also had some completely different. You had some that I hand't even thought of! Great job!

    ReplyDelete